Skip to content
Free US shipping on every order, no minimum 30-day returns on factory-sealed product
Tillerhouse
Saved
  • Football
  • Baseball
  • Pokémon TCG
  • Other cards
    • Basketball
    • Magic: The Gathering
    • All other cards
  • Shop by format
    • Hobby boxes
    • Jumbo boxes
    • Blaster boxes
    • Mega boxes
    • Full cases
    • All products
  • Shipping
  • Returns & Refunds
  • Warranty
  • Privacy
  • Cookies
  • Terms of Service
  • Accessibility

Returns & Refunds

You have 30 days from delivery to return factory-sealed products. Here is exactly how returns and refunds work at Tillerhouse.

Last updated October 20, 2026Tillerhouse2200 Emmons Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11235

On this page
  1. 1 Return window
  2. 2 What can be returned
  3. 3 What cannot be returned
  4. 4 Damaged or incorrect products
  5. 5 How to start a return
  6. 6 Return shipping cost
  7. 7 Inspection
  8. 8 Refunds
  9. 9 Manufacturer issues
  10. 10 Before you dispute a charge
  11. 11 Contact

At a glance

Return window
30 days from delivery
Condition
Factory sealed only
Return shipping
Free, with a prepaid label
Refund
Usually within 10 business days after inspection

1 Return window

You may return an eligible product within 30 days of the date it was delivered, as shown by the carrier’s tracking. To start a return, contact us within that window; the product does not need to reach us by the last day.

2 What can be returned

Returns are accepted on factory-sealed products in the condition you received them: the original manufacturer seal intact and no damage caused after delivery. A case must be returned complete, with all of its boxes, still in its sealed manufacturer carton.

SituationCan it be returned?Who pays return shipping
Factory sealed, within 30 days of deliveryYes, for a refundTillerhouse
Arrived damagedYes, for a replacement or refundTillerhouse
Not the product you orderedYes, for a replacement or refundTillerhouse
Opened or unsealedNo, final saleNot applicable

3 What cannot be returned

Opened or unsealed products are final sale. This includes any box, pack, tin or case with a broken, cut or removed manufacturer seal, and any case whose inner boxes have been removed. Trading card products are sold sealed because their contents are randomized; once a seal is broken we cannot resell the product or verify what it contained.

A return is also not possible because of the cards you pulled or the value of a product. Contents are set by the manufacturer and are not known to anyone before the seal is opened.

4 Damaged or incorrect products

Important — contact us before opening

If a product arrives damaged, or is not what you ordered, email support@tillerhouse.shop with your order number and photos of the product and the outer packaging before opening the product, so the seal and condition can be confirmed.

You may choose a replacement or a refund, and we pay the return shipping.

5 How to start a return

1

Tell us what you are returning. Email support@tillerhouse.shop with your order number and the product you want to return.

2

Get your label. We will reply with return instructions and a prepaid return shipping label.

3

Pack and ship. Pack the product securely so it arrives in the same sealed condition, attach the label and hand it to the carrier. Keep the drop-off receipt until your refund is complete.

Please do not send unannounced packages

Do not send a product back before contacting us. We cannot match unannounced packages to orders reliably, and we cannot reimburse postage on packages sent without a prepaid label from us.

6 Return shipping cost

Returns are free. We pay the return shipping on every eligible return by sending you a prepaid label, and there is no restocking fee.

7 Inspection

When a return arrives, we check that the manufacturer seal is intact and that the product is the one we shipped. If a returned product does not meet the conditions in this policy, we will contact you to explain why and to arrange for it to be sent back to you.

8 Refunds

Once the return has passed inspection, we refund the product price to your original payment method, usually within 10 business days, and confirm it by email. Your bank or card issuer may take additional time to post the credit to your account. Shipping on your order was free, so there is no shipping charge to refund.

9 Manufacturer issues

Problems with the contents of a sealed product, such as a missing guaranteed hit or a miscut card, are handled by the manufacturer under its own policies. See our Warranty Policy for who handles what and how to claim.

10 Before you dispute a charge

If something is wrong with an order, please contact us before disputing the charge with your bank. Most problems are resolved faster directly, and a dispute can delay a refund we would otherwise issue straight away.

11 Contact

Questions about a return: email support@tillerhouse.shop or write to Tillerhouse, 2200 Emmons Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11235.

Still have a question?

Send us a message and a real person on our team will get back to you, usually within one business day. Include your order number if you have one.

Email support@tillerhouse.shop
  • Emailsupport@tillerhouse.shop
  • HoursMon–Fri, 9:00 AM–6:00 PM ET
  • AddressTillerhouse, 2200 Emmons Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11235
Need help choosing a box? Email us and we will help you pick the right format, year or case. Monday to Friday, 9:00 AM to 6:00 PM Eastern Time.
support@tillerhouse.shop
  • Factory sealedEvery box ships with the seal intact.
  • Free US shippingOn every order, no minimum.
  • 30-day sealed returnsOpened product is final sale.
  • Tracking emailedSent when your order ships.
Tillerhouse

Authorized dealer of Topps, Panini, Pokémon, Bowman, Leaf and Upper Deck. Factory-sealed boxes and cases only.

Shop

  • Football cards
  • Baseball cards
  • Basketball cards
  • Pokémon TCG
  • Magic: The Gathering
  • Other trading cards

Help

  • Track your order
  • Shipping
  • Returns and refunds
  • Warranty
  • FAQ
  • About
  • Blog
  • Contact

Contact

Tillerhouse
2200 Emmons Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11235
support@tillerhouse.shop
Monday to Friday, 9:00 AM to 6:00 PM Eastern Time
© 2026 Tillerhouse. Product and brand names are trademarks of their respective owners. PrivacyTermsCookiesAccessibility

Your cart (items: 0)

Products in cart

Product Details Total
Subtotal $0.00
Shipping and discounts calculated at checkout.
View cart
Go to checkout

Your shopping cart is empty

Return to shop

Notifications